Rating Plans – Simplifying Decisions
Looking for a fair electricity plan in Texas shouldn’t feel like solving a puzzle.
That’s why we built a rating system that cuts through the complexity and rewards providers who play it straight with clear pricing.
We keep score of who’s truly looking out for you and who’s trying to hide costs in the fine print.
Because at the end of the day, you deserve to know exactly what you’re paying for without having to decode marketing speak or hunt for hidden fees.
Here’s how we evaluate electricity plans:
Plan Rating Score Overview
Category | Maximum Points |
---|---|
Value | 50 |
Rate Structure | 35 |
Rate Consistency | 15 |
Flexibility | 30 |
Early Termination Fee | 15 |
Satisfaction Guarantee | 10 |
Contract Length | 5 |
Features | 20 |
Renewable Energy | 15 |
Sign-up Incentives | 5 |
Total Possible | 100 |
Value – Getting What You Pay For
Rate Structure (35 Points)
We look at how straightforward and honest the pricing is. Complex pricing often hides costs that can surprise you on your bill.
Flat Rate Plans (35 points)
These get our highest score because:
- What you see is what you get – one consistent rate
- Your rate stays the same whether you’re using 800 kWh or 1,200 kWh
- Makes budgeting easy – at 12 cents/kWh, 1,000 kWh will always cost $120
- No math needed to predict your bill
Bill Credits (15-20 points)
- Under 1,000 kWh usage (20 points)
- Over 1,000 kWh usage (15 points)
Bill credits can save you money, but they’re tricky:
- Most common is a $100 bill credit at specific usage levels
- Example: If you get a $100 credit at 1,000 kWh but use 999 kWh, you’ll pay $100 more that month
- Lower usage targets are easier to hit consistently
- Missing the target by just 1 kWh means no credit at all
Free Time Periods (10 points)
Free nights and weekends plans have set schedules:
- You know exactly when electricity is free
- Example: From 8 pm to 6 am, all electricity usage is free
- Great for running your washer, dryer, and dishwasher during free hours
- But daytime rates are usually higher to make up for free periods
Seasonal Discounts (8 points)
These plans offer discounts during specific months:
- Example: Lower rates in June-July for “summer savings”
- But August is often just as hot with no discount
- You can’t predict when you’ll need more air conditioning
- Weather changes can affect how much you actually save
Rate Consistency (15 Points)
Rate consistency shows how much your price per kWh changes at different usage levels:
Very Consistent (15 points)
- Less than 1 cent difference
- Example: Rate only changes from 12 to 12.9 cents per kWh
- You might see your bill change by around $10 each month
- Makes budgeting predictable
Somewhat Consistent (12 points)
- 1-1.5 cent difference
- Example: Rate changes from 12 to 13.5 cents per kWh
- Your bill could jump $15 a month if your usage changes
- Small changes that won’t surprise you
Moderately Consistent (8 points)
- 1.5-2 cent difference
- Example: Rate changes from 12 to 14 cents per kWh
- Bill swings of $20 could be coming your way
- You’ll notice these changes on your bill
Less Consistent (4 points)
- 2-3 cent difference
- Example: Rate changes from 12 to 15 cents per kWh
- Watch our for up to $30 bill spikes
- Significant monthly bill variations
Not Consistent (0 points)
- More than 3 cent difference
- Example: Rate changes from 12 to 16 cents per kWh or more
- You could be looking at $40+ jumps on your bill
- Large bill swings month to month
Flexibility – Freedom to Change When You Need To
Early Termination Fees (15 points)
This is what you’ll pay to end your contract early. Remember: Texas law protects you from early termination fees if you move.
No Fee (15 points)
- Switch plans anytime without penalty
- Take advantage of lower rates when available
- No cost to change if the plan isn’t working for you
- Maximum flexibility
Standard Fee (10 points)
- $150 or less to cancel
- Most common fee amount in Texas
- Example: If rates drop 3 cents per kWh, paying $150 to switch could still save you money
- Consider potential savings versus the fee
High Fee (5 points)
- More than $150 to cancel
- Makes switching expensive even when better rates are available
- Could keep you stuck in a higher-rate plan
- Less flexibility to respond to market changes
Satisfaction Guarantee (10 points)
This is your trial period to make sure the plan works for you:
Best Protection (10 points)
- 60+ days to switch to any provider
- Time to see two monthly bills
- Switch to any plan you want
- No questions asked
Good Protection (6 points)
- 60+ days, same provider only
- Two billing cycles to decide
- But can only switch to other plans from same provider
- Limited options if unhappy
Basic Protection (4 points)
- 30 days to switch to any provider
- Might only see one bill
- Quick decision required
- Any provider available
Limited Protection (2 points)
- 30 days, same provider only
- One billing cycle
- Limited options
- Quick decision needed
No Protection (0 points)
- No guarantee
- No trial period
- Locked in immediately
- No flexibility
Contract Length (5 points)
The length of your contract affects both price security and flexibility:
12-Month Contract (5 points)
- Most common contract length
- Covers a full cooling and heating season
- Long enough for price stability
- Not too long if market rates drop
Extended Contract (3 points)
- 24 or 36-month terms
- Longer price protection
- Might miss lower rates
- Less flexibility to change
Other Terms (1 point)
- Month-to-month or non-standard lengths
- Could be higher rates
- Your contract might end when prices are at a peak
Features – The Extra Benefits
Renewable Energy Content (15 points)
Texas’s average renewable energy content for electricity plans is around 33%. Here’s how plans compare:
100% Renewable (15 points)
- All power from renewable sources
- Mainly Texas wind and solar
- Zero fossil fuels
- Maximum green energy
Mostly Renewable (12 points)
- 50% or more renewable energy
- Well above Texas average
- Mixed energy sources
- Strong environmental benefit
Average Content (8 points)
- Near Texas average (33%)
- Typical power mix
- Standard renewable content
- What most Texans get
Below Average (5 points)
- Less renewable than Texas average
- More fossil fuel power
- Minimum green energy
- Basic power mix
Sign-up Incentives (5 points)
Remember: These “free” gifts are usually built into your rate:
Premium Gifts (5 points)
- Smart thermostats or home devices
- Retail value usually $200+
- Higher electricity rates to cover the cost
- Check total plan cost carefully
Large Gift Cards (3 points)
- $75 or more in gift cards
- One-time bonus
- Small monthly impact
- Compare total plan costs
Small Gift Cards (1 point)
- Under $75 in gift cards
- Minor incentive
- Very small monthly value
- Focus on electricity rates
No Incentives (0 points)
- No extra perks
- Often better electricity rates
- Straightforward pricing
- Pure electricity service
What Our Star Ratings Mean for You
★★★★★ Outstanding Value
These plans excel in what matters most:
- Clear, straightforward pricing
- Consistent rates that make budgeting easy
- Reasonable fees and good flexibility
- Strong consumer protections
- Additional features that add real value
★★★★ Smart Choice
Solid plans that get the basics right:
- Good, competitive rates
- Standard consumer protections
- Reasonable fees and terms
- Some useful extra features
★★★ Solid Option
Basic plans that might work for specific situations:
- Standard market rates
- Basic protections and terms
- May have some trade-offs
- Could be a good fit depending on your needs
Remember: The highest-rated plan isn’t always the best for your specific situation.
Use these ratings as a guide, but consider your household’s unique needs when making your choice.
How to Choose the Right Plan
Don’t get overwhelmed by all these electricity options. Finding the best plan for your home can be quick and easy with the right approach and tools.
Sign Up and Save With Live Link™
Say goodbye to guesswork and hello to personalized savings with Live Link™. This innovative feature taps into your actual energy usage data to find the perfect electricity plan for your home. Here’s why Texans love Live Link™:
- Effortless Accuracy: No more digging through old bills or estimating your usage. Live Link™ securely pulls your real consumption data with just a click.
- Tailored Recommendations: Get plan options customized to your unique energy habits, not generic estimates.
- True Cost Clarity: See the full picture of your electricity costs, including how seasonal changes affect your bill.
- Big Savings: By matching you with plans that fit your actual usage, Live Link™ could save you hundreds each year.
Ready to find your best plan? Try Live Link™ now – it’s free, fast, and could be your ticket to lower electric bills.
Don’t settle for one-size-fits-all plans. Let Live Link™ do the heavy lifting and find you a plan that truly fits your home’s needs.
Looking for a DIY approach?
This 2-minute video explains everything you need to know ⤵️
Call us at 855-441-3030 Monday through Friday, 8:30 a.m. to 6:30 p.m., or Saturday, 9:00 a.m. to 4:30 p.m.
Any product or company names, marks, or logos shown on this page are the property of their respective owners. ComparePower is an unaffiliated, independent marketplace. Get unbiased, accurate information backed by our commitment to editorial integrity.